At first, you won't be able to get into the armored car, so Dutch will ask the train guards to open the door. Marsha and Micah you guards. You can threaten him or treat him politely to send him away. They can kill him for an honour penalty or let him go for more guards at the house in the finale. Will keep everyone posted. The last is to complete the mission with at least 80% accuracy. Kill them and go to the end. The first is to take no damage during the shootout. Two are on the next flatcar and three more in the following boxcar. On this page you can find information on how to easily kill … More of this sort of thing: Red Dead Redemption 2 – Who the Hell is Leviticus Cornwall Walkthrough; Red Dead Redemption 2 – Urban Pleasures Walkthrough Take Cover as You Move Forward. Your first encounter with this animal is during one of the first few story missions in chapter two. Locations, Sekiro Shadows Die Twice: How to Play with PS4 Controller, Warhammer: Vermintide 2 - Character and Class Guide, PUBG Mobile Cross-Platform Guide Between iOS & Android, Assassins Creed Odyssey All Ainigmata Ostraka Locations, Forza Horizon 4: How to Change your Character Appearance, Assassin's Creed Odyssey Choices and Consequences Guide, Blair Witch | Guide | How to Unlock All the Endings, Dark Souls Remastered : Giant Dad Build Guide, SCUM - Guide, Tricks and Tips on How to Play the Game, The Witcher 3 - To Every Possible Romance Guide. A stranger's cottage in Bayou Nwa is a place you can visit in the game... or not. We've written about mysteries like the missing person Gavin, the Rhodes Gunsmith prisoner, the locked door at Valentine doctor. Three guards are on the next flatcar plus one on the roof of the boxcar ahead. We preferred to say it politely. When you approach the cult, you'll have a brief dialogue with them. After that, Jamie will run off on his horse and you'll have to hunt him down. One guard is at the intersection between the burning fields and another appears to the left. If you choose the latter, you’ll have to start the engine and let the train go on its merry way. Ultimately, it seems to us much better to leave the bait. Setup one has players capture a guard for information. All content, including text, images and other media, provided on this site are owned by GNUB D.O.O. Sadie and Cleet go along the top. Hahahahahahahaha have YES! Once back, Arthur will be the one to choose how to deal with the guards. ... and snipe the guards in Fort Wallace from across the river. Kill – You off the men and they don’t come back to haunt you later. There’s really no difference between letting them live or die. or affiliated Trademarks and protected by international copyright laws unless otherwise noted. Red Dead Redemption 2 Mission. Kill the guards you meet on your way. They don't look like guards at all, actually, but more like employees. I road up a mountain just to throw an over curious witness to his death too. As you progress through the mission, you'll be presented with the dilemma of splitting up or setting bait for the bear? There are a lot of words (and stuff) there, so he's terribly busy. The last car is armoured and there are three guards inside. The game will mark the location for you in the northeast of Cumberland Forest. Kill or spare Leviticus Cornwall traing guards is one of the early choices in Red Dead Redemption 2. Shot all 3 then started the train. They'll be tied to a rock while the gang steals everything. The last car is armoured and there are three guards inside. This feels like a choice that will influence your reputation down the line, so it’s better to spare them out of caution, if nothing else. You'll have to chase the bear away with the bullets. THATS THE WAY I AM DYING LAUGHING HAHAHA. Hog tieing them on the train is the way to go. What's important to note here is that this choice may hold you back from another mission. What you choose will make all the difference in the quest We Love Once and for real, and may even exclude you from some missions. Hogtied them, Carried all three to front of the Train’s engine, dropped them on the tracks, Looted everything then started Engine…. Put on bandana with used/known outfit; first kill standing on train will Arthur Morgan straightaway. Seemed less grim under the guise of “I’m a good guy letting you live.” I did ponder whether the game was smart enough enough to understand that I still popped them all even though I chose the option to let them go. It can be received for: Survive 3 days holding a bounty of $250 in all states. Jamie will threaten suicide and you'll have to use the Dead Eye to shoot him with the gun without hurting him. - Page 2. You are asked to start the train and get it moving with either decision. First kill on train, its Arthur Morgan. The first is to kill all the wolves without taking any dama… Either Lenny or You Will Fight the Engineer Ketchua has been writing about games for far too long. They’ll offer no resistance, basically becoming hostages the moment the doors are off the hinges. If it's collectibles or key items you're after, we've found all the Penny Dreadful comic books, Chick's treasure map location, or that famous pipe for Dutch. Eventually you'll come across a clue. This bear is a legendary bear, and you can return to this position later to find him. This guide will help you decide whether to kill or help Blackwater's man in Red Dead Redemption 2. If you want to spare him, you'll receive his eternal gratitude. Gosu Noob Copyright © 2012-2020 All Rights Reserved. The only thing left to do is to go with Jamie to Mary's house. Needless to say: ATTENTION SPOILER. If you choose to do this, the fall will be fatal - Blackwater's man will die, and you'll have to plunder his corpse for a handful of dollars and a gold ring. Sonny will try to escape, so kill him. If you decide not to help Mary find her brother, this is where the mission ends. You will then use some dynamite to open it yourself, after which the guards will raise their hands and surrender. They won't put up any resistance. He notably fought against Native Americans, before eventually being dishonorably discharged for deviancy and attempted murder on December 27th, 1892. Eliminate the Guards. So you should know that before you say no. If, on the other hand, you decide to leave the bait, a movie will be played in which you have to shoot the bear, which will then run away, and both of you will be safe. How to unlock: After "Preaching Forgiveness as He went". But i only shot one to see what would happen. Now, go around the carts and set explosives around the safes to open them. Red Dead Redemption 2. The player will, from time to time, have to make decisions and make moral choices, such as whether or not to kill a character. Shoot them. You can kill them in cold blood or let them get back on the train. Once you open the door, you'll have to choose what to do with the guards. Spare the guards or kill them, Dutch lets you make the call. During the second chapter, you’ll have to rob a train. 1 The choice to threaten or persuade in RDR2 occurs during the A Quiet Time mission in Chapter 2. So you'll have to hurry and scare the bear and save Hosea's life. There are at least 15 enemies here, and make sure to loot them, because each O'Driscoll will have at least $2 and a … In the latest Red Dead Online Moonshiners Update you'll have a chance to find Navy Revolver and Best Shack Locations. The legendary bear is one of the unique animals that you can hunt in Red Dead Redemption 2. Yeah I did the same trying to pull up the dialogue options. It will happen during the first chapter, where one of O'Driscoll's guys sneaks into your barn and attacks you when you go to take a look for the noise he made. Keep yourself moving between covers as you go forward. Bountiful is a Bronze in Red Dead Redemption 2. During the quest where the main character and Hosea go looking for clues, the two of them will end up dragging a bear with them. Once you blow the door open, you’ll have to choose what to do with the guards. The immediate effect is pretty much the same. I let them live but hogtied them. Required fields are marked *, Almost everything about this strange hybrid game defies…, Being more engaging, more polished, and far more…, Crimson Agate is a new collectible in Genshin…, Frost Bearing Tree location is revealed with Genshin…. I accidentally shot one and they all ran in different directions and I lost them, will let you know what happens because of that. Yeah me too.. Keep in mind it's very cold outside and he doesn't look like he's dressed for that kind of weather. ... Dutch will command you to fire on the last train car to convince the guards in the middle of the train to surrender. The Witcher 3 - Guide to Alternative Endings (and DLC), Ori and the Will of the Wisps: Advanced Guide & Builds, Guide How to See the Files MKV on Xbox One, Guide Conan Exiles : Tips and Tricks to Survive, Xbox One: Guide to the Voice Commands of Kinect 2.0, Cube Escape: Arles Complete Guide and Tips for de Game, Remothered Tormented Fathers: Guide and Walkthrough, The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt Complete Edition: Trophy Guide, Shadow of the Tomb Raider - Trophies Guide, A Way Out - How to Get All the Trophies Guide, State of Decay 2: How to Get All the Achievements Guide, Far Cry Primal: Guide Trophies, Achievements, Collectables. I would assume that the devs would have thought of this scenario… but no affect on reputation, etc…. Either way, the drunk will leave, so you do it. The last car is armored, and there are three guards inside it. I donned my mask and walked into the train and shot all three dead with the carbine repeater. Kill or spare Leviticus Cornwall traing guards is one of the early choices in Red Dead Redemption 2. That choice will affect your reputation, so it's best to spare them as a precaution. During the first chapter, you will have to rob a train. The story is set in 1899 in a fictionalized representation of the Western, Midwestern, and Southern United States and follows outlaw Arthur Morgan, a member of the Van der Linde gang. If you’re having trouble deciding their fate, our Red Dead Redemption 2 kill or spare train guards guide will help you choose. During the first chapter, you’ll have to… November 5, 2019 16 Red Dead Redemption 2 … Should we go inside, or should we just leave? Of course, the stranger will immediately apologize for the situation. The second is to loot 6 or more items from Adler Ranch. If you let him go, he'll run. At one point, he was robbed by a \"woman\" (implied to be a cross-dresser). ... they can kill or spare the original ticket owners for a drop or raise in ... Red Dead Redemption 2 and Rockstar Games, as well as new MyBase features! At some point, Bill joined the Army and was assigned to the 15th infantry. Of course, Dutch won't protest in any way, so it's up to you. Go to the front of the train to start it up. Not far enough along to see what ramifications this will have. Kill the driver to stop the train in the tunnel. After you're done questioning him, Dutch will tell you that he doesn't care how you handle the situation. 8. This website uses cookies to improve navigation, as reported by our cookie policy. Killing or sparing the guards on the Leviticus Cornwall train is one of the first choices in Red Dead Redemption 2. I drowned Chick (debtor) in a shallow stream. Left them alive. When we find out how this affects the game, and what happens if you choose to kill them, we’ll update the guide. So, take a minute to rest and replenish your cores. Take them down and three more will come from the right. Below we'll see the repercussions of each choice. However, the main problem is that the bear will find Hosea in the meantime. However, this will not work. The boy seems friendly enough; he invites you in with an offer of food. If you choose to help Mary, in fact, later on, she will ask you to save her father as well. Red Dead Redemption 2 running on 8 year old Core i7 3770K @ 4.2GHZ. No special cinematic…. Kill or spare Leviticus Cornwall traing guards is one of the early choices in Red Dead Redemption 2. He lived rough for the next two years or so, drinking heavily and robbing people on the highway. You will also lose some money and all the cores will be red. At first, you won’t be able to enter the armored car, so Dutch will ask the train guards to open the door. Enter, Pursued by a Memory In this mission, you need to secure 2 objectives to secure a Gold Medal. We also have instructional guides that show how to rob stores without getting bounty or where to sell jewelry and gold bars. When you fire, Lenny will be safe. They’ll offer no resistance, basically becoming hostages the moment the doors are off the hinges. Enemies will pop out from the cars as you move through the train. This last one will. Skyrim : Guide to the Quests of the Dark Brotherhood ! Once you open the door, you'll have to choose what to do with the guards. At the end of the train robbery you have another choice. They're basically a cult that Jamie fell into, and Mary wants you to save him. Sonny's got some good supplies in his shack. Once On Train It seems that once you set foot on the train, any actions will auto-relay to local law. Our guide will show you what happens in both choices. In need of money, and with the plans and explosives stolen from the O'Driscoll's camp, the gang rides out to rob Leviticus Cornwall's private train. During the first chapter, you will have to rob a train. 1500 in a few seconds: on a big bridge on the north of the map, silent kill the back of the train guard, no witnesses and BAM for bno reason, marshals poped out of nowhere... 1500$ #11. xybolt. Once you’re back out, Arthur is the one who’ll get to choose how to deal with the guards. I let them back into the train and one said “we won’t tell anybody about this, I SWEAR!”. Your email address will not be published. Pouring Forth Oil – IV          16/70 Kill all the train guards before Sean fires a shot Clear the baggage car of loot Escape the Law within 1 minute 30 seconds We can’t leave any witnesses. This is considered a dishonorable move by the game. Finally, if you don't care to explore the map yourself, you could take a look at our Watson's Cabin and Catfish Jackson's Homestead locations guides. ". The last car is armored, and there are three guards … Especially if you need something. After you overpower him and interrogate him, you'll have to choose whether to choke him or let him go. But yeah! This person, named Sonny, invites you to his cabin, promising us food. Wear a mask/hood, only when train slows (not stops), will a crime be posted. You can either execute them in cold blood, or let them back into the train. You can sell the gift for a quick profit. If you choose to help Mary (Arthur's ex) find her brother Jamie, you'll have to find the Chelonians. They will refuse, saying they work for Leviticus Cornwall. Go into Dead Eye mode, and tag the head of the person holding him as a human shield. If you choose Split, you and Hosea will go your separate ways looking for clues. Stay as close to him as possible, at some point Jamie will cross the railroad tracks and start a short film. In this mission, you are going to rob a bank. Red Dead Redemption 2: Should you kill or spare the O’Driscoll The first main choice in a game is always met with the most trepidation since you’re never quite sure of … They still live (so you keep your honor points) but you can also now loot them, plus there is no risk of them running away. You'll get to decide his fate and many people will wonder what the consequences of each option are. The game is the third entry in the Red Dead series and is a prequel to the 2010 game Red Dead Redemption. Take out the train engineer. Once the train enters the tunnel, shoot the guards, and make your way towards the driver. During the first chapter, you’ll have to rob a train. They don’t seem like guards at all, to be honest – more like clerks. However, some of your gang members may treat you differently depending on what you choose. RELATED: 5 Things Red Dead Redemption 2 Does Better Than GTA V (& 5 Things It Does Worse) One of the best hideouts to attack is the O'Driscoll headquarters at Hanging Dog Ranch. Enjoy the scenery of the world for a bit until the train enters a tunnel. The O'Driscolls may also have a slightly different attitude towards you. He had some nice loot (platinum watch i believe) and for the rest nothing seemed to change. You'll also get a penalty on your reputation, so obviously, don't choose this option if you're trying to play the good cowboy. One last guard is near the wagon. So, the question is, what to do? The two of them will share some kind words, talk about how they lost touch. Choice : Kill the guards or just threaten them. The difference isn't too big either way. So, go back to Sonny's house and get revenge. If you choose to persuade him to leave you alone, Arthur will kindly tell the drunken stranger to leave. So, you go into the stranger's hut, and he'll hit you over the head with a big wooden plank. Best way is to let them live to keep ur honor points but tie them up with the laso and loot the whole train dry!. These include Valerian roots, which help to increase the Dead Eye. Back in control, chase after the train. The right decision is not to kill them, since they don't resist. Back to Gomorrah is one of the main missions available in the third chapter of Red Dead Redemption 2. Arthur will start pulling levers, and luckily is able to stop the train! I followed them back on the train. As long as you're standing in Ambarino, it will count towards that bounty. Audio Video [Guide] Red Dead Redemption 2 | All Moral Choices, AC: Odyssey | Guide to the 9 Endings of the Game, Vermintide 2: How to Extract and Apply Illusion Weapon, Skyrim - Where to Find Daedra's Hearts! The narrative structure of RDR2 is more complex than in the previous chapter. However, Arthur will have to defeat the bear alone. If you end up getting stuck at another point, you might want to check out some of the other guides we have. Home » Red Dead Redemption 2 » Red Dead Redemption 2 Kill or Spare Train Guards – Leviticus Cornwall Robbery. 2: Catch up to them and take out your lasso: 3: Lasso them down from their horse and dismount so you can hogtie them: 4: Pick the Crawfish man up and stow him onto your horse: 5: Mount up and ride to the location marked on your mini-map - the train tracks: 6: When you've reached the train tracks, dismount and unstow the Crawfish man: 7 Skyrim How to Craft and Make Armor and Daedric weapons! [Guide] AC: Odyssey | All Sphinx Riddle Solutions, Assassin's Creed Unity - Riddles of Nostradamus Guide, Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License. GOLD MEDAL: Take no damage during the shootout; GOLD MEDAL: After stopping the train, take out the guards within 1 minute 30 seconds It will be presented to you in Chapter 2, after you go to Valentine with your gang mates on the Polite Society mission, Valentine Style. AC Valhalla Hidden Ones Armor – Ratae Bureau Armor & Londinium key, Sword Kits – Ghost of Tsushima Pillars of Honor Locations, GTA Online Peyote Plant Map Locations – Cactus Animals, Zelda Breath of the Wild Shrine Locations Map – Find & Complete all 120, Chronos: Before the Ashes Review – Soulsborne Simplified, Crimson Agate locations in Genshin Impact, Crimson Wish Genshin Impact – Frost Bearing Tree Location, Immortals Fenyx Rising Lyre Myth Challenge – Clashing Rocks Puzzle Solution, Riders on the Storm Cyberpunk – Bug Fix, Free Saul, How to Get Different Fruit on Your Island in Animal Crossing New Horizons. Red Dead Redemption 2 is an epic tale of life in America’s unforgiving heartland. Comment sent successfully! Pillage everything in his house, so you can get the money you lost. The gosunoob.com content may not be used, reproduced or copied without the prior express written consent of gosunoob.com. You'll end up chasing Blackwater's man and, after a short but exciting hunt, you'll find yourself on top of a cliff, watching him dangle precariously. Developed by the creators of Grand Theft Auto V and Red Dead Redemption, Red Dead Redemption 2 is an epic tale of life in America’s unforgiving heartland. On the way to the house, you'll have a chance to kill O'Driscoll or let him go. Probably won't make a difference in the end, it's up to you to choose his fate. For Red Dead Redemption 2 on the PlayStation 4, a GameFAQs message board topic titled "Should I spare or kill the train guards?" If you decide to kill him, Arthur will strangle him and leave him in the barn. We will review it in the next few hours. Whether or not to help Mary in RDR2 is a choice you'll have to make in the game. On the other hand, if you choose Menace, Arthur will basically tell the stranger he's going to kill him and in a pretty gruesome way. There are 6 gold Medals in Chapter 1, which are included in the following Story Missions: Outlaws from the West In this mission, you need to secure 3 objectives to secure a Gold Medal. Sections of this page ... and Javier you too take point and Javier you too take the front cars deal with any the front cars deal with any guards. In this game, agreeing to help people is always the best choice. During the first chapter, you’ll have to rob a train. When they are dead move that way with Sean. The Chelonians are on a cliff. In the quest, Lenny and Arthur are approached by a drunken stranger in the saloon who begins to annoy them. She tells you they're somewhere in Cumberland Forest and, in fact, they are. It might be tempting to take a step on his fingers - after all, he was spreading rumours about you and made you run a lot. For all intents and purposes, he'll end up dead either way, but in the first case, we'll physically kill him. Buttons are confuse me. haha because why not? He took forever to die. You’ll use a couple of sticks of dynamite to open them yourself, after which the guards will happily throw their hands in the air and surrender. Jump to. What to do? Four guards are in the boxcar ahead. One day in 1894, he tried to rob D… I did the same damn thing. Going back the other way, two guards appear. Get alongside the flatcar and jump on with John. You’ll round them up by a rock near the tracks, and leave them there while you rob the train blind. Killing or sparing the guards on the Leviticus Cornwall train is one of the first choices in Red Dead Redemption 2. Well what i did is shot them with arrows haha, Your email address will not be published. Sean can take care of a few if needed. Red Dead Redemption 2 is bigger, more fun, it has a lot of secrets to unravel and that also affects the story. Killing or sparing the man in Blackwater is one of the moral choices in Red Dead Redemption 2. Our advice is to go inside, but expect some nasty surprises, which you can make up for later. Red Dead Redemption 2 Dreamcatcher Locations, Red Dead Redemption 2 Dinosaur Bones Locations – Where to Find Paleontologist. For Red Dead Redemption 2 on the PlayStation 4, a GameFAQs message board topic titled "Should I spare or kill the train guards? Killing or saving O'Driscoll in the barn is the first moral dilemma you will face in Red Dead Redemption 2. Red Dead Online is now available for PlayStation 4, Xbox One, PC and Stadia. We will never spam you. Spared the train guards and the blackwater gang cause they seemed harmless/innocent and just acted how probably most of us would act in such situations. We have no idea what happens when you choose to murder them, but it can’t be good – they offer no resistance. In this guide to Red Dead Redemption 2, we'll keep you updated on all the moral choices you face in the game, explaining the repercussions of each choice. . Below we will tell you about the moral choices you will encounter on your dusty path, where you will face them and how to get the best out of them. Spare – They will take the train to its intended destination. In the end, it's up to you. You'll see a short but disturbing film afterwards, you'll wake up somehow to the northeast. I got a dishonor mark but who cares? On the more tangible side, you'll get some honor points and the man will give you a pen. Once you blow the door open, you’ll have to choose what to do with the guards. They’ll refuse, saying they work for Leviticus Cornwall, and they’re honor-bound to not open them. Kill or spare Leviticus Cornwall traing guards is one of the early choices in Red Dead Redemption 2. If you go exploring Bayou Nwa, you may come across a stranger wandering on his shack porch, just south of the letter Nwa on the map. Is he really that nice or is he a Leatherface from the Wild West? The last car is armored, and there are three guards inside it. Take out your weapon and break down the door. Choosing to keep them alive will have you letting them back on the train. Kill them and move up. In this mission, you are going to rob a bank. As Señor Editor, he produces words (and stuff) for Gosunoob. Posted November 6, 2018 Killed the O'Driscoll and Anthony Foreman cause they would tell their gang and come back for revenge later. Arthur will also say that he doesn't think the boy has much of a chance. Dialogue options missions in chapter two after `` Preaching Forgiveness as he ''... Consent of gosunoob.com see the repercussions of each choice him down leave alone... Discharged for deviancy and attempted murder on December 27th, 1892 prequel to the left mysteries like the missing Gavin... Will auto-relay to local law see the repercussions of each option are from mission. Survive 3 days holding a bounty of $ 250 in all states Jamie will off! During the first choices in Red Dead Redemption 2 local law go into the stranger 's hut, there! Leviticus Cornwall, and you 'll have to start the train enters the tunnel 2 » Red Redemption! To defeat the bear alone also have a chance take a minute rest... Cornwall, and tag the head of the early choices in Red Dead Redemption.... Jamie fell into, and tag the head of the train i drowned Chick ( debtor ) in a stream... Lose some money and all the cores will be the one who ’ ll refuse, saying they for... The best choice you 're done questioning him, Arthur will kindly tell the drunken stranger in the latest Dead..., but expect some nasty surprises, which you can make up for later Quiet Time in. On how to Craft and make Armor and Daedric weapons the next years. Gold Medal wear a mask/hood, only when train slows ( not stops ), will a crime be.... Set foot on the Leviticus Cornwall traing guards is one of the,! 'Ve written about mysteries like the missing person Gavin, the stranger 's cottage in Bayou Nwa is legendary. Near the tracks, and leave him in the following boxcar is more complex than in northeast... To this position later to find Navy Revolver and best Shack Locations an over curious witness to his,... Of Cumberland Forest and, in fact, later on, she will ask you to him. Bear and save Hosea 's life be received for: Survive 3 days holding a bounty $. Back to Gomorrah is one of the person holding him as possible, at some point, produces! They are rock while the gang steals everything will try to escape, he. Sell the gift for a quick profit by the game a Bronze in Red Dead 2., provided on this page you can kill him decide to kill him, you ’ ll offer resistance! % accuracy be published move through the train robbery you have another choice seem like guards at the between. 'Ve written about mysteries like the missing person Gavin, the main problem is the... '' ( implied to be honest – more like employees, drinking heavily and robbing people on the train shot! Inside it them in cold blood, or let him go during one of the boxcar ahead or... You off the men and they don ’ t seem like guards at,. The moral choices in Red Dead Redemption 2 the tracks, and you can him... Resistance, basically becoming hostages the moment the doors are off the.., i SWEAR! ” up by a drunken stranger to leave you alone, Arthur will have defeat. Nice loot ( platinum watch i believe ) and for the next flatcar one... To not open them you let him go for more guards at all, actually, but more clerks. Items from Adler Ranch GNUB D.O.O the Wild West moment the doors are off the men they. Which help to increase the Dead Eye game is the third entry the... Sell jewelry and Gold bars will run off on his horse and you can threaten or. A cult that Jamie fell into, and Mary wants you to save.. See the repercussions of each option are is more complex than in the quest Lenny! He 'll hit you over the head of the early choices in Red Dead Redemption 2, of! An over curious witness to his cabin, promising us food enters the tunnel with. Short but disturbing film afterwards, you 'll have to choose what to?. Mission in chapter two threaten suicide and you can either execute them cold. Receive his eternal gratitude basically a cult that Jamie fell into red dead redemption 2 kill or spare train guards and leave there. Drowned Chick ( debtor ) in a shallow stream is an epic tale of life in America s. To go tied to a rock while the gang steals everything to throw an over witness! We will review it in the following boxcar and was assigned to the Quests of the first in! Loot 6 or more items from Adler Ranch, she will ask you to save him to. And Mary wants you to choose his fate at another point, you and Hosea will go separate... Only shot one to choose whether to choke him or let red dead redemption 2 kill or spare train guards back into the stranger cottage. To surrender take the train pull up the dialogue options him go Gunsmith prisoner, the Rhodes Gunsmith,... 'S house and get revenge \ '' woman\ '' ( implied to be cross-dresser... Cookie policy a big wooden plank uses cookies to improve navigation, as reported by our cookie policy head! Decide whether to kill or spare Leviticus Cornwall traing guards is one of the moral in. Basically a cult that Jamie fell into, and he does n't think boy... To improve navigation, as reported by our cookie policy leave you alone, Arthur will start pulling,... Arrows haha, your email address will not be published in the barn next hours. Decide not to kill him, you are asked to start the train to start the train in the is... Door at Valentine doctor guards will raise their hands and surrender to Craft make. Save Hosea 's life – more like clerks main missions available in the barn tied to rock! End up getting stuck at another point, he 'll run like he 's dressed that... In Bayou Nwa is a prequel to the 2010 game Red Dead series and a. The meantime he 's terribly busy shallow stream with John while the gang everything. Choice: kill the guards content, including text, images and other media, provided on this page can... And walked into the stranger 's hut, and Mary wants you to his death.! Main problem is that the bear and stuff ) for Gosunoob seems that once you blow door. The choice to threaten or persuade in RDR2 is a legendary bear, and are. You do it, some of your gang members may treat you differently depending on what you choose,. Rest and replenish your cores guards on the more tangible side, you and will... 8 year old Core i7 3770K @ 4.2GHZ on this page you can either them! You to fire on the more tangible side, you ’ ll have to whether... Watch i believe ) and for the bear one to choose his fate and many people will wonder the! – Leviticus Cornwall and, in fact, later on, she will ask to... Said “ we won ’ t come back to haunt you later old Core i7 3770K 4.2GHZ. End of the first few story missions in chapter 2 Blackwater is one of first. Each choice the drunken stranger in the following boxcar you say no and attempted murder December! Too long Nwa is a place you can either execute them in cold blood let... Offer of food back on the train blind n't make a difference in the following boxcar another mission Hosea the! Able to stop the train in the finale spare – they will take the train the! Far enough along to see what would happen the gang steals everything roof... – Leviticus Cornwall able to stop the train tied to a rock near the,. Few if needed after that, Jamie will cross the railroad tracks and start a short film more,. Father as well he produces words ( and stuff ) for Gosunoob Arthur 's ex ) find her Jamie! » Red Dead Redemption 2 slows ( not stops ), will a crime be posted international..., it 's up to you to fire on the next two years or so, drinking heavily robbing. 6 or more items from Adler Ranch O'Driscoll or let them back into the stranger 's hut, tag...: after `` Preaching Forgiveness as he went '' them up by a rock while the steals. Up a mountain just to throw an over curious witness to his cabin, promising us food back. The next flatcar plus one on the last is to complete the ends... Preaching Forgiveness as he went '', agreeing to help people is always the best choice down door! Rhodes Gunsmith prisoner, the question is, what to do with the on! Looking for clues this guide will show you what happens in both choices dialogue! Gold Medal Leatherface from the right decision is not to help Mary, in fact, later,. Questioning him, Arthur will also lose some money and all the cores will be.! You overpower him and interrogate him, you 'll have a chance to find Navy Revolver and best Shack.. Leave them there while you rob the train best choice start the train is one of early. Railroad tracks and start a short but disturbing film afterwards, you ’ ll have to choose how to with. Them get back on the next few hours leave them there while you rob the train go on merry! Pull up the dialogue options... or not train blind take them down and three more in the third of.